Santiago’s Seafood Market in Indiana

"This is now my go to spot for a shrimp po-boy and fried shrimp!! I can't say enough on how delicious their food is, how great the service is, and how accommodating the staff is on every visit. Indy had such a void after losing Williamson's, which was the ONLY place I'd get shrimp dinners from but now that Santiago's is here, I'm fulfilled. The bread is top tier, fresh and chewy. The cilantro fries are perfectly cooked and tasty. The key lime pie.... Santiago's 10 out of 10 recommend!!"

"The food was so good and the service so nice! Juan(?) offered advice about which were his favorites and was very warm and friendly. We shared an oyster poboy and whole catfish dinner with fries and fried okra. If we lived closer, I'd like to go a few times a month and try everything on their menu."

"Very impressed with the quality of their fresh fish. Definitely worth the price- which was reasonable, by the way. The service was lovely too. The atmosphere was boring and bland, which is actually a compliment. It felt homey and safe."

"I was in town for my family reunion and found this place. I try to eat local whenever I travel and this had something for everyone. This place is gem. Such a wide selection of seafood and is fairly priced. The mood is causal, you order at the counter and your food is brought out HOT and fast. The crab cake was the most impressive as there was little filler. Loved that they had jamaica on the menu. Only misstep was the mac and cheese. I think they used pimento cheese and that gave it a very unappealing taste. Otherwise, you need to stop by."

"Babe beat seafood in the city hands down!!!! Homemade greens with smoke Turkey not a lot of steams so not can greens but fresh! The staff is amazing! You can get fresh seafood and cook at home or they will cook it for you! It’s a family restaurant so they take pride in their food and service! Promise won’t be disappointed!"

"Santiago’s Seafood Market is a great spot for fresh seafood. We were grateful to find the mussels we needed for a recipe we wanted to try, and everything looked fresh and well stocked. They also cook food to order, with plenty of grilled, raw, and fried options. It’s a helpful resource to have nearby, and I’m glad we found it."

"Absolutely incredible fish and amazing service! The food came out super fresh and everything was so delicious! Would recommend!!"

"So glad we found this place! The catfish nugget dinner was delicious and a large portion. Their crab cake dinner was also good, definitely more crab than cake! And the sides, we tried 4 different ones and were not disappointed: collard greens (made with turkey) had the perfect texture, saltiness and smokiness; Mac n cheese was flavorful, creamy and cheesy; fried okra was not too salty and the batter stayed on the okra; lastly, the cilantro fries were perfectly seasoned and crispy. We also picked up coconut rice and teriyaki sauce to make dinner which was so convenient. The woman and man that helped us place or order and delivered the food were super nice and you can tell they were proud of this restaurant (not sure if they were the owners, but it felt like it with how great there were to their customers)."